Made with just 8 ingredients, this delicious apple butter pie has the same custardy texture as pumpkin pie but tastes like an apple pie! It’s incredibly easy to prepare and can be made a day or two in advance.

A slice of apple butter pie garnished with whipped cream.

For years, I thought that apple butter was only good for slathering onto toast, biscuits, or pancakes. But when I had a jar of apple butter that had been sitting in my pantry for months, I decided to test it out in a pie.

I was honestly shocked at how good this pie ended up turning out! It tastes just like a slice of homemade apple pie, but with a pumpkin pie-like consistency. It’s the perfect dessert for pie lovers who can’t choose which one to make for Thanksgiving.

This apple butter pie is made with just a handful of basic ingredients, which you probably already have sitting in your pantry and fridge. Since this pie has to be chilled in the fridge for the filling to set, it’s also a perfect make-ahead dessert for the holidays!

Recipe Video

Separate dishes of apple pie spice, apple butter, and pie dough.

Ingredient Notes & Substitutions

Pie Crust

To save time, you can use a store-bought pie crust. I personally prefer making my homemade pie crust recipe though because it’s flakier and tastes better. Keep in mind that if you’re using a thinner, store-bought pie crust (like Pillsbury), you may need to reduce the baking time when you’re blind baking it.

Apple Butter

Feel free to use store-bought to make things easier! If you want to go all out, you can make your own apple butter too.

Spices

If you don’t have apple pie spice or can’t find it, you can replace it with ½ teaspoon cinnamon, ¼ teaspoon nutmeg, and ¼ teaspoon allspice.

How To Roll Out Your Pie Crust

Rolling out pie crust is pretty easy once you get the hang of it, but there are a few things I recommend doing to make the process a little easier:

  • Lightly flour your work surface.
  • Place the disc of pie dough onto the floured surface.
  • Dust the top of the pie dough with flour before using a rolling pin to roll it out.
  • Give the dough a quarter turn every few rolls to prevent it from sticking to the counter and make sure it rolls out evenly. (Don’t forget to lightly flour the dough on top and underneath too!)

I usually roll mine out until it’s about 12 to 13 inches in diameter and an ⅛-inch thick. You can check to make sure it’s large enough by turning your pie plate upside down and holding it over the circle of dough. You want the pie crust to be slightly larger than the pie plate so it fits snuggly into the dish and you have a little extra to crimp the edges.

Want to see how it’s done? Watch my pumpkin pie video for a more detailed walkthrough. (The video should start at the 50-second mark to show me rolling out a pie crust.)

How To Blind-Bake The Crust

I know this is an extra step, but whenever I make custard pies I always blind bake the pie crust first. This basically just means that you’re partially baking the crust before you add the filling to prevent the crust from ending up soggy.

Once you’ve rolled out the pie crust and transferred it to your pie plate, you can trim and crimp the edges. Then, place the pie crust in the fridge for 15 minutes while the oven preheats to 400ºF. This is going to give the butter and shortening a little time to firm back up and keep your crust super flaky.

After the oven is preheated, line the pie crust with either parchment paper or aluminum foil (don’t forget to take it up the sides!). Then, fill the crust with pie weights. If you don’t have any pie weights, you can use dried beans or rice instead.

Bake the crust with the pie weights for 15 minutes, then remove them (along with the foil/parchment paper) and bake it for another 5 minutes. This gives the bottom of the pie crust a chance to bake a little too before you add the filling.

Need a little more help? I also have a more detailed post on how to blind bake a pie crust. If you’re more of a visual learner, you can watch me blind bake a pie crust and explain it more in my pumpkin pie video too.

Tips For Making The Filling & Baking The Pie

  • Don’t over mix the filling. Over mixing can add more air to the filling and cause it to puff up and then sink or crack as it cools. To prevent this, gently whisk everything together until it’s just combined.
  • Feel free to add a little more sugar. Apple butter is usually pretty sweet, but if yours isn’t, you may want to add more sugar. Just keep in mind that you may need to increase the baking time slightly if you do.
  • Don’t over bake it! This can cause the filling to crack. You’ll know it’s time to remove the pie from the oven when the outside edges are set, but the center has a slight wobble when you move the pan. Keep in mind that the filling will continue to set up more as it cools.
  • Use a pie crust shield. This prevents the edges from burning. I usually just place mine on top after I add the filling, then transfer the pie to the oven. This prevents me from having to open the oven door while the pie is baking too.
An overhead view of a baked apple butter pie.

Topping & Garnish Ideas

I love to top this pie with either whipped cream or salted caramel sauce (or both!). A sprinkle of apple pie spice, cinnamon, or nutmeg also makes for a prettier presentation.

If you have some leftover pie crust, you can also make some pie crust garnishes. You can use some small cookie cutters in different shapes (like leaves or apples), bake them separately, and place them on the pie right before serving.

A slice of apple butter pie garnished with whipped cream. A bite is missing.

I love the spiced apple flavor of this pie, and that I don’t have to peel and slice any apples to make it! If you make this recipe, I’d love to hear how it turned out. Enjoy!

A slice of apple butter pie topped with whipped cream.

Apple Butter Pie Recipe

Prep Time: 30 minutes
Cook Time: 1 hour 10 minutes
Cooling & Chilling Time: 5 hours
Total Time: 6 hours 40 minutes
Made with just 8 ingredients, this delicious apple butter pie has the same custardy texture as pumpkin pie but tastes like an apple pie!

Ingredients

Servings: 8 slices

Pie crust

  • 1 pie crust homemade or store-bought

Apple Butter Filling

  • 1 ½ cups apple butter (450 grams)
  • 1 ¼ cups heavy whipping cream (300 ml)
  • ⅓ cup packed light brown sugar (70 grams)
  • 3 large eggs at room temperature
  • 1 teaspoon pure vanilla extract
  • 1 teaspoon apple pie spice (or ½ teaspoon cinnamon, ¼ teaspoon nutmeg, and ¼ teaspoon allspice)
  • ½ teaspoon salt

Instructions
 

  • To prepare the pie crust: Preheat the oven to 400°F (204°C).
  • Roll the pie crust dough out until it’s about 12-inches in diameter. Carefully transfer the dough to a 9-inch pie plate (make sure it’s at least 1 ½ inches deep). Gently fit it into the pie plate, trim any excess dough, and crimp the edges. Transfer to the refrigerator to chill for 10 to 15 minutes while the oven finishes preheating.
    1 pie crust
  • Remove the pie plate with the chilled crust from the fridge. Line the pie dough with parchment paper or foil, making sure to cover the bottom and fit it snuggly in the corners and up the sides, then fill with pie weights (dried beans or dry rice work well for this step too!).
  • Bake the pie crust for 15 minutes. Remove from the oven and remove the parchment paper (or foil) and pie weights. Return the pie crust to the oven and bake for an additional 5 minutes or until the bottom of the crust looks dry/no longer doughy.
  • Remove from the oven and set aside to cool slightly. Reduce the oven temperature to 375°F (190°C).
  • To make the apple butter filling: In a large mixing bowl, gently whisk together the apple butter, heavy cream, brown sugar, eggs, vanilla, apple pie spice, and salt until smooth and well combined.
    1 ½ cups apple butter,1 ¼ cups heavy whipping cream,⅓ cup packed light brown sugar,3 large eggs,1 teaspoon pure vanilla extract,1 teaspoon apple pie spice
  • Pour the filling into the partially baked pie crust.
  • Bake for 40 to 50 minutes, until there’s just a slight wobble in the center. If the edges of the pie crust begin to brown too much, cover them with a pie crust shield or aluminum foil. I prefer to place a pie crust shield on the crust before baking the filling and leave it on for the entire baking time.
  • Remove from the oven and transfer to a wire rack to cool completely (about 2 to 3 hours). Cover tightly, then transfer to the fridge to chill for 3 to 4 hours or until it’s firm.

Notes

Storage Instructions: Once the pie has cooled completely, cover it tightly and store in the refrigerator for up to 4 days. 
Freezing Instructions: This pie will freeze well for up to 3 months. Let it cool completely to room temperature, then wrap tightly with plastic wrap, and store it in a large freezer bag. Thaw in the fridge overnight.
 
Cuisine: American
Course: Dessert
Author: Danielle Rye
Did you make this recipe?Mention @livewellbakeoften on Instagram or tag #livewellbakeoften.